Featured post

Comparing Cats and Dogs (Or Christians)

C. S. Lewis was so far ahead of his time as a Christian thinker. The following excerpt from Mere Christianity 1952 expresses my deeply held thoughts on the problems sorting people of faith. I’ve been both castigated and celebrated for similar views.

Comparing Cats and Dogs

(The complexity of comparing Christians and non-Christians)

The situation in the actual world is much more complicated than that. The world does not consist of 100% Christians and 100% non-Christians. There are people (a great many of them) who are slowly ceasing to be Christians but who still call themselves by that name:

some of them are clergymen. There are other people who are slowly becoming Christians though they do not yet call themselves so. There are people who do not accept the full Christian doctrine about Christ but who are so strongly attracted by Him that they are His in a much deeper sense than they themselves understand. There are people in other religions who are being led by God’s secret influence to concentrate on those parts of their religion which are in agreement with Christianity, and who thus belong to Christ without knowing it.

For example, a Buddhist of good will may be led to concentrate more and more on the Buddhist teaching about mercy and to leave in the background (though he might still say he believed) the Buddhist teaching on certain other points. Many of the good Pagans long before Christ’s birth may have been in this position. And always, of course, there are a great many people who are just confused in mind and have a lot of inconsistent beliefs all jumbled up together. Consequently, it is not much use trying to make judgments about Christians and non-Christians in the mass. It is some use comparing cats and dogs… in the mass, because there one knows definitely which is which. Also, an animal does not turn (either slowly or suddenly) from a dog into a cat.  But when we are comparing Christians in general with non-Christians in general, we are usually not thinking about real people whom we know at all, but only about two vague ideas which we have got from novels and newspapers. If you want to compare the bad Christian and the good Atheist, you must think about two real specimens whom you have actually met. Unless we come down to brass tacks in that way, we shall only be wasting time.

Quotes from Mere Christianity, Part 84

C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity (1952; Harper Collins: 2001) 208-209.

Featured post

Happy Dad’s Day – True Heroes Never Die




On this Father’s Day, I want to remember the two fathers I was blessed with.

The first, my birth father, Elmore ‘Matt’ Matheson, was taken away by death in 1967 when I was ten-years-old. He was everything a Dad should be and if I’m half the father he was, I’m good.

The second followed many years later when I was still in the darkness and my thirties. It took me ten years to call him Dad, but he earned the title and the respect that goes with it. He died four years ago after a battle with cancer. At his funeral, the minister used Philippians 2:3-4 to describe him. Though he had never met Hank Smoyer, he came to this conclusion after talking with family. He treated the angels and devils of relatives and offspring with the same free-flowing grace, and that best describes him.

Philippians 2:3-4
Let nothing be done through selfish ambition or conceit, but in lowliness of mind let each esteem others better than himself.  Let each of you look out not only for his own interests, but also for the interests of others.

My birth father barely made fifty-years-old and I have a decade plus on him now. He invades my life and thoughts daily more than fifty years since I saw him last.

They both are heroes and I find myself to be fortunate indeed for having them bookend my life. The following piece I wrote in their honor, the first version coming while Hank Dad was still alive.

~~~Last years Intro~~~~

I wrote this piece several years ago while reflecting on the ongoing effects of my birth father’s life and death nearly fifty years ago. And, the maniacally dysfunctional life I lived for too many years after his death.  The story did not end the same, thank God. I was fortunate that another hero came along, and my life became bookended by a second father. He also passed on, but only after many sacrificial years of demonstrating what authentic heroes are composed of and how they never die.

To my birth father Elmore ‘Matt’ Matheson and my second father Howard ‘Hank’ Smoyer, this piece is dedicated.

~~~True Heroes Never Really Die~~~~

Like a rain-soaked cloud on a stormy day, his death blanketed my mind infusing every pore. My breath felt strangled, and every hope voided leaving only sadness in its wake. My young soul simmered to bursting, but without any relief in sight.


My dad was gone. Goddamnit!


Ten-year-old boys are not equipped to suffer a wrenching loss such as death. That was the main attraction this day. The closing act designed to erase my father’s life from this earth.


Center stage surrounding the shiny casket stood garish sprays of flowers you only ever see at horse races—and funerals. From where I sat neatly filed away between Mom and Grandma, I could see the waxen features of Dad’s strong face protruding from the polished box. Archaic piped-in hymns kept the mood at a full-tilt grim, and Death’s boots stomped an indelible print into my miserably shattered soul.

We family members were segregated well away from the larger gallery of—mere spectators—those obligatory witnesses to our collective grief. A week later they would adjust their lives to do without Ellmore ‘Matt’ Matheson. Five decades (and counting) later he continued to occupy a front row seat in my day-to-day life.

Despite the drowning sadness of that day, my faith was at its peak; I clung desperately to a vain hope that Dad would shake himself awake and climb from that wretched box. Then we could go back home to the beautiful humdrum of our lives.

The crowd queued up to file passed the open casket.

Not me. No, sir. No way.

I WOULD NOT be part of that ghastly parade.

More than one well-meaning relative stopped, and with a gentle pat on my hand encouraged me to come along and view his corpse. What could they have been thinking? Was convention so indispensable they found it necessary to heap even more torment onto such a young boy?

A horde of silent whispers grew in my head as one by one every spectator struggled not to look in my direction. Couldn’t they see that I had the most skin in this game?

And they were worried about tradition!

Surrounded by my family and friends, I felt utterly abandoned and the only person with enough care or courage to sit with me that day and say, “Everything will be alright,” lay stretched out in the casket. He would have done so whether I was his son or not.

I was an only child, but now had less than nothing.

Why had I been singled out to be cheated of a father?

Where was God while my dad lay dying? (In a hospital room I was deemed too young to visit)

What, besides pure evil (perhaps ignorance) could let a child bounce down such wicked tangents as those jagged rocks of death?

An unfamiliar rage crept like a wolf on the prowl circling through the dark forest closing in on me. Life was no longer innocent. Hunched around its dying fire for warmth, my innocence, and ambient peace were stolen away in such small bites that I wouldn’t recognize what had happened till years after anger bloomed with a life all its own.

It wouldn’t be until twenty-five years later that the fiery bitterness would finally begin to cool. The treasure Dad had stealthily hidden away would finally see daylight.

Since that ugly day so long ago, I’ve amassed a growing corps of personal heroes, yet, compared to a father, they play only minor supporting roles in the story of my life. I look to them to spur my skill, talent, and gifting, to inspire me to strive in character and craft. But, the Drum Major stands his post ahead of them all. Barely a day goes by without his lessons and examples working their way to the surface of my decisions, actions, and exploits. It’s incredible how much soul Dad was able to pack into the short ten years he guided my growing little life, almost as if he knew his time would be short.

If I die knowing my life had even half as profound an effect on my children and grandchildren as Dad had on mine, my life will have been well lived.

My earliest memory of Dad was when I was three or four years old. Somewhere in Europe, I was hanging from the doorway of a car and peeing into a malevolent rainstorm. He drew enough bravery from me that night to voluntarily dangle from an open door and do my business.

As years went on, he taught me the much more noble art of growing things. I sold produce to our neighbors, born from my vegetable plot. Still clear in my mind is Dad helping me discover the mystery of black spots that showed up on the leaves of my plants: Charcoal in the soil. Today no one could accuse me of being a good gardener, but how many lessons in commerce, responsibility, and hard work grew in that little garden? Over time, those lessons would grow into factory management and eventual business ownership.

Dad was able to correct single-handedly my pigeon-toed feet by simple, kind and consistent reminders not to walk like that.

When I show my toddler son how to throw a ball or I must admonish his behavior, Dad still whispers in my ear the right words to say. On one of our many spontaneous early A.M. fishing trips, I caught a crab, a monster by seven or eight-year-old standards. Its fearsome claws awed me, but Dad saw an opportunity for a lesson in courage.“It’s not as scary as it looks,” he said. “Put your finger in the pincers and see.”

I drew back with a fearful, “No!” Dad exerted the mild pressure it took to get me to do anything, and I put my finger in the claw. He was right of course. Just a little pinch. Today I know that most things are fiercer in appearance than they are in reality.

Anything Dad asked me to do, I would do. And defiance, so commonplace in young people today, was nearly inconceivable for me. His ‘suggestions’ had the power to pull daring, hard work and sacrifice from a timid little boy who would rather not be those things.

Running home one day, from the threats of a bully (older and taller than I) Dad turned me around and marched me back to face Dale Rudd. Up until the very moment that Dad said, “Fight him,” I fully expected he would take care of the menace for me. That battle looked more like a dance than a fight (I’m sure Dad knew it would). Lesson learned- Never back down from a threat, the slightest temptation to do so sets me to thinking of Dad standing next to me.

He and I built a slot car track out in the garage. It was on a large board with pulleys that could be pulled up to the rafters and out of the way. How many simple things such as the use of tools and more complicated things like patience and persistence did that project teach?

One of my fondest recollections was going to work with Dad during my summer vacations. He had retired after twenty-seven years in the Army and now worked for the Santa Ana Parks Department. Eating lunch with him and his coworkers made me feel much older than my seven years. I spent the day catching frogs while he worked. We took the frogs home in Chinese food containers, and on the ride home in a cavernous four-door blue and white ‘55 Chevy they all disappeared. They were small but not minute. We never did find them.

Above all, I think Dad taught me to be kind. It was his standout trait and showed in everything he did. He never explained, it was just part of who he was. You could be sure not to mistake his kindness for timidity or weakness, though. He was never afraid to stand up for himself or an innocent victim of someone else’s abuse. He had some strong views on world affairs that wouldn’t be very user-friendly today.

In those days, a family outing could be to simply drive around. It was during one of those that Dad accidentally hit and killed a small dog. I remember sitting in the car with Mom as he picked up that dead Wiener Dog and carried it through the neighborhood looking for its owners so he could tell them he was sorry.

If in the end, I turn out half as kind and compassionate as Elmore H. Matheson, I’m good.

The bitter memory of not being allowed to visit my dad in the hospital where he died sits aching in my head like an abscessed tooth. Too young they said. I’m glad it’s not that way today. In that at least, our society has grown more compassionate.

Paramedics’ forcing my dad to ride the gurney downstairs was the last time I physically saw him alive. His repeated remonstrations to be allowed to walk down the stairs under his own power still ring in my head. Every day that he was in the hospital, I looked forward to talking with him on the phone. I don’t recall what we talked about, but I know both of us fully expected him to come home; until the day, I returned home to a gray room and a tearful mom.

“Sit here Mikey,” she said patting the cushion next to her.

The day of his funeral is still clear as yesterday. I was 10-1/2 years old. No young son should have to bury his father. Unfortunately, for us in this violent, disease prone world, it happens much too often.

I wasn’t scared to view the body but refused to see my hero like that. He was Superman, strong and without a doubt loved me. He had the answer to every question. How could he do so from that box?

It has taken many years of life in the raw to learn that a hero like him could never really die but lives on in every breath, decision and deed of my life.

Today he is just as strong if not stronger, and now forty-nine years down the road many of the seeds he planted in the first decade of my life are just now bearing their fruit. That’s a real hero and one that can never really die.


Many years later, I was an adult stuck in a tailspin; my mom married another great man. It took me several years to see that and reconcile him as a father to me. But I am glad that I did.

In discussing this thought with a good number of people, I found it hard to find more than a couple that had even one GOOD father in their life, and I’ve had two. I understand my tremendous good fortune.

While writing this piece my second father was battling cancer from which I fully expected him to recover. He died just as I was finishing.

Howard “Hank” Smoyer earned the right to be called my Dad. He was not an ‘also ran,’ but another real hero that will never die. It would take another story to tell you why.

Mixed up in the midst of all my madness and trouble, God used two true men to sculpt my life, and they are carving away still.

True heroes certainly never die.